Pair of Impressive Collections Coming to the Auction Block

Just when you think there can’t be any more impressive athlete collections to come to market, SCP Auctions and Goldin Auctions make some impressive announcements on the eve of The National Sports Collectors Convention.

Goldin Auctions has announced the sale of the “Hobest” Eddie Murphy Collection, dating back to 1912, and SCP Auctions will offer the circa 1893 cabinet photos from Cy Young’s personal collection.

Goldin Auctions
Goldin Auctions is proud to present the Honest Eddie Murphy Collection – member of the Philadelphia A’s 1912-15, and Chicago White Sox 1915-21 –  on display at the Goldin Auctions booth at The National Corporate Booth No. 443

EddieMurphyRingsHonest Eddie Murphy was a member of four World Series teams during his impressive MLB career which began as a 20-year-old in 1912.  He was the starting left fielder with the Philadelphia A’s that reached consecutive World Series behind the likes of Eddie Plank, Home Run Baker and Eddie Collins. The A’s won it all in 1913 and then lost in 1914. He returned to the World Series in 1917, winning the title with the 1917 Chicago White Sox and then losing as a member of the infamous 1919 “Black Sox” and that is where he gained his nickname “Honest” because he did not participate with eight of his teammates in the 1919 Black Sox scandal. In 2,373 career at bats, Murphy batted .287 and swiped 111 stolen bases. According to his grandson, he would order food in restaurants for teammate Joe Jackson who was unable to read the menu.

MurphyPinAll items from the collection are fresh to the hobby and consigned by his grandson Edward Murphy. They have remained in family possession for 100 years, and each comes with a letter of provenance from Edward Murphy.

Highlights from the collection include:

  • 1910 A’s World Championship Ring (issued at 1939 Baseball Centennial)
  • 1917 Chicago White Sox World Championship pin
  • 1913 World Series presentation glass bat (only one in existence). This bat is currently on display at the Corning Museum of Glass in Corning, N.Y., where it has resided for the past 20 years. This bat was presented to Murphy on the field prior to Game 2 of the 1913 World Series on October 7, 1913.

SCP Auctions
SCP auctions is presenting one of the most remarkable 19th-century baseball card related discoveries in the history of the hobby: A group of seven cabinet cards that once belonged to one of baseball’s most legendary figures, the great Cy Young. The collection is the ultimate marriage of intrinsic quality and dream-like provenance. The group represents Young’s Cleveland Spiders from the 1893 period, in addition to a Spiders team composite cabinet produced in 1896. The centerpiece is a staggering representation of Young himself produced by the Pifer & Becker Photo Palace of Cleveland, Ohio.

Cy YoungcabinetphotosFour other Pifer & Becker cabinets in the collection feature Young’s Cleveland teammates Chief Zimmer, Patsy Tebeau, Ed McKean and Hall of Fame legend Buck Ewing. An additional cabinet in the fraternity featuring Cupid Childs was produced by John H. Ryder. Each of the four Pifer & Becker cabinets bear the same images featured in one of the 19th-century collecting world’s Holy Grail card issues, the 1893 Just So Tobacco card set. All Just So Tobacco cards, which exclusively feature Cleveland Spiders players, are exceedingly rare. It has been estimated that fewer than 25 examples in total are known in the entire collecting world, with 14 different players represented.

cyyoungcabinetPrior to the historic discovery of a single tattered example featuring Buck Ewing in 2010, it had long been speculated whether or not he had been included in the series. The matching images of these one-of-a-kind cabinets with their Just So counterparts leaves no doubt that these cabinets are the parents of that issue. Our research has produced evidence of only one other similar Pifer & Becker cabinet (Jimmy McAleer) in hobby circulation confirming a long held belief among collectors that there remains yet to be accounted for members in the Just So ranks. It’s not often that any piece of cardboard bearing the likeness of a ball player could be compared to Just So in terms of rarity, but when items such as these cabinets exist in singular form, rarity is moot.

Property of Denton T. “Cy” Young
This grouping of seven cabinet cards was the personal property of Cy Young. Each of the cards has an identifying player notation written in Young’s own hand. In the case of Young’s own cabinet, this amounts to the addition of his autograph, as well as his first name notation “Cy”. The McKean example bears both McKean’s autograph (d.1919) and Young’s written identifier. The 1896 team cabinet has been signed by Young on the mount. All of these cabinets were mailed together by Young in an accompanying envelope addressed to Harry Erickson of famous Cleveland jewelry store The Cowel & Hubbard Co. on Euclid Avenue. Young’s handwritten name and return address appear in the upper left corner. The postmark cancellation date is illegible, however the type of postage stamps used on the envelope indicate a mailing date of around 1933, suggesting Young may have owned these cabinets for as long as four decades. The accompanying transmittal envelope is completely addressed in Young’s hand and includes his notation “Photos” above the postage. Having recently emerged from a Cleveland area estate, these objects represent a landmark discovery on many levels.

SCP Auctions is privileged to unveil them for the first time publicly at the 2014 National Sports Collectors Convention in Cleveland, Ohio, their city of origin. These items, along with many other highlights from our August 6-23 Mid-Summer Classic Auction can be viewed at the SCP Auctions booth (1001P, 1005P, 1100P, 1104P) from July 31-August 3.

Leave a Reply